Monday, June 07, 2004

(Not) The Father Dowling Mysteries

Below is a post to excellent Frayster The_Bell regarding the historical existence of Jesus, based on a somewhat sloppily written book with a seemingly excellent research base and engaging and (to my mind) convincing thesis.

___________________
excerpt from The_Bell's post:

For what it is worth, I also agree that there was probably a historic Jesus and even that he was a specific person rather than a conglomeration of the myriad "the-end-is-near" preachers, mystics, and prophets knocking around Judeah at that time. However, I do agree that the writers of the Gosepels probably borrowed some of the stories, imagery, etc. from other sources, just like the story of Genesis borrows a lot from Babylonian myth and other legends. The use of metaphor does not make the historical Jesus any less real or the spiritual Jesus any less significant for believers.


Sorry it took me a while to respond...

just curious, have you read "The Jesus Mysteries" by Freke & Gandy? While certainly an uneven book, their points that there is little corroborating evidence for Jesus' existence historically seems compelling.

I would suggest you read it, as their full argument is more than the sum of its parts, but the thing that rang true for me is that we know many details about the life of Mohammed, for example, and he lived in ~300 CE, right? The records of Jesus' activities seems critically sketchy, even compared to people of his own time. We have a lot of knowledge about Alexander the Great, about Caeser (Julius and Augustus), about a number of scholars from classical times and earlier, and many of these have multiple historical sources. I've never heard of a source outside of religious texts discussing Jesus (which, as Freke and Gandy point out, you would expect had there been as much stir about him as there is supposed to have been). They were unable to find indictments against him or a record execution in the Roman's rather complete (they claim) preserved legal records, and they find no contemporary or early philosophers disucssing him, or any grouping of any people with names remotely like those of the 12 apostles.

There were several "Jesus" found in the historical records, but none who were in the right place at the right time; they also noted that the imagery of "God on a cross" did not appear in Rome until some 100 or so years after Christ is thought to have died; even then, this representation was not of Jesus, but a graffiti meant to mock Dionysis worshippers.

There is certainly something left to be desired in their arguments, but all the same, I haven't heard any rebuttals of their more supportable arguments. The best I've heard is "we have to view the Bible as a historical document", which even if you do, it has a hard time standing up because it is not only self-contradictory, but has limited corroboration in other contemporary documents.

I'm curious to know what you think; and I strongly recommed the book, despite my reservations about their writing style and occasional weaknesses.

Slate posts cont'd....

This next is a thesis on whether Plan B, the "emergency contraceptive" recently rejected for over-the-counter availability by the FDA.

I have to admit, this is not my area of expertise (and a female friend of mine feels squeamish as to whether men should even have any input into women's reproductive decisions), and also, that I didn't actually read the Slate article that I posted under in the Fray. But really, the question I decided to address was posed by another Frayster, la_rana, who was asking another poster, Isonomist, if children, who have not fully developed adult-reasoning, should nevertheless have the adult choice of using Plan B. I tried to reformulate his question and answer it here; I then reformulated my response into the more stand-alone screed below.

________________________

Subject: Progress CAN be made -- and it HAS been made in other countries.

I hate to upset my countrypeople, but while we may have most of the world's weapons of mass destruction, other countries are beating us at the weapons of mass contraception.

Forgive me for that, it was irresistible.

There's a report linked to at the end showing the sex ed and available contraception... work. Sorry, kids. We're one of the most abstinence-only focused, and getting the worst results. You may have to cry "coincidence," or conclude that G*d is punishing us again (for, I don't know, gay marriage, or not burning the things a woman sits on during her "unclean" time, or maybe it's all of the masturbation).

I don't know exactly where I fall on Plan B, but to engage the rhetorical point here, I think the issue is not whether the full capability for decisions determines whether Plan B should be available or not; I think the question is, which set of consequences should a child have the option of selecting (in their admittedly poor judgement)?

This sounds like a weird formulation, even to me.

But let's try it. If Kid A makes a bad decision (or, as Iso points out, is coerced as young kids usually are), they have a limited set of options, but still options. The ideal option selection would be 1) Tell a responsible, caring, understanding adult, and make the decision in consultation with them. This option has two problems: there may not be this adult available (i.e. there may only be the sexually abusive father, or any of many less drastic problematic adults), and the kid may not have the wherewithal to bring this to an adult's attention.

Option 2) The kid tells no one, starts showing sooner or later, and then goes one of several courses: an illicit abortion to avoid excess adult involvement (i.e. parents); the parents (or some other adult) becomes aware of it and helps the child get as safe an abortion as possible; or the adults find out and the child for seem reason bears the baby to term (which for a young child is a potentially lethal course).

Option 3) The kid uses Plan B, available at the drug store; maybe she gets sick from side effects, maybe she doesn't, but perhaps her secret stays safe (with two more possible ancillary courses: adults never find out, and the sexual activity/abuse may continue, or the adult finds out and approaches the child or the child reconsiders and approaches an adult, and hopefully changes the circumstances).

I'm not sure if that's too complicated or too simplistic a synopsis.

Pressing onward, in this universe of choices, I would say it's not easily predictable what children with their under-developed reasoning may do. However, if we look at the options, I think most would agree 1) is in all ways preferable. 2) is risky, and can turn out anywhere on a gradation of "best" to "worst" possible results. And then option 3) seems to address the immediate problem; i.e. it has a dramatically lower chance of death (safer than a young child bearing a child, and safer than a backalley abortion [though I don't know if these are actually common or used as a spectre more often, but it certainly is a possibility and a bad outcome]), but it allows the child to possibly continue being sexually active or being coerced into sex.

In a universe of bad options, it seems to me not to be a simple factor of "should adult consequences be available/imposed on a child who made the adult decision of sex (or was forced into it". It's "what universe of adult choices should a possibly confused child be able to make?" And I would say in that regard, Plan B seems to be a choice that on the whole, we'd *want* as part of the universe of choices for a child; after confiding in a responsible adult, it seems like the second best possible outcome -- the child may suffer side effects, but gets to avoid the risks of abortion and the risks of bringing a child to term, as well as avoiding the substantial adult burden of *raising* a child, which is a heavy burden, especially for someone without the adult that they can/should talk to. (Plan B also avoids a later, usually more difficult decision of whether to abort or not if your beliefs follow the idea that life begins some point after conception but before the last trimester).

So I think it's just one of those "best of a bad situation" cases. If it's prescription only, that requires the child have the sense of mind to go to a doctor. If it's available and relatively safe, it's just another sub-optimal choice among many. The only way to truly address this is to continue doing all we can within reason to prevent abuse, and to educate [fray.slate.msn.com] and make options [www.pub.umich.edu] available [www.agi-usa.org] as we do so. We can do it -- other countries have much lower teen pregnancy (and abortion) rates; we have to decide what "moral" and "adult" and "consequences" means to us in an imperfect universe, in the US's imperfect universe, and then we'll be ready to catch up.

HC
www.iamj.blogspot.com

The Slate Diaries

Hey...

What follows will be a series of re-posts from my Slate alias, HopefulCynic. I will try and contextualize the missives, as some are in response to articles on Slate or other writers. But, on the other hand, I'm in a hurry to get out of here, so context may have to be back-added later for some. Tchau.

__________________________________

(in response to the continuing feature in Slate analyzing Bush & Kerry campaign adds)

Hey, call me crazy, but isn't this the same crap all real thinkers about politics decry from the media every election -- an analysis of the process and no analysis of the substance?

The deconstruction of the ad campaign was amusing at first. But now, looking at two men with great analytical talents, I'm going "who cares whether John Kerry's commercial "optimist" makes him seem "optimistic" because "optimistic" candidates usually win under a hackneyed cliche?

I think it's telling the cliche is mentioned, partially discredited, and then the conversation continues as if whether or not this commercial works as a play towards that cliche. Are you kidding me?

I don't know why Slate has chosen to follow the time-honored process of form over substance; maybe it's because that's all "the media" knows how to do. Or maybe it's the ratings thing. I don't know.

What I also don't know, but would like to: we've heard Bush talk about Kerry's record, and Kerry talk somewhat about Kerry's record. How about an analysis of Kerry's record, unrelated to the claims of either party? How about a 3rd party review of what he's voted for, why, and what patterns there were? How did the bills work out? How has he campaigned in the past? Has he followed through on his promises (or grading on a curve, has he followed through on campaign promises more often than others?). How has his rhetoric changed over the years; who has funded him, how does that compare to his votes? How come the CPI book The Buying of the American Presidency [www.publicintegrity.org] started a whole series of indepth discussions in the media? Sure, "corporate funding" as a story comes and goes, but how about instead of keeping tab on Kerry's rhetoric, we keep tab on who's given how much, in the past and present, and how that lines up with his votes? Is it significant to no one in the media but the Daily Show and Bill Moyers that Charles Lewis claims to have confirmed the intuitive truism that politicians will be more responsive to those that have given them more money?Does it matter nothing to our system, or matter less than commercials, that tit-for-tat seems to be the norm?

I don't think this can be excused with "there's too little to follow up on or keep a story running", or "people aren't interested." If Saletan and Weisberg are truly diligent journalists, and deserving the higher esteem I give to Slate than "mainstream" news, why do I have to see the same 3-ring circus in Slate? I get more information about the history, content, and actual operation of our government in the Fray -- and as much as that's a compliment to Fraysters, it speaks very poorly for Slate.

How much analysis does Kaus give us that's not related to image and "gotcha"? When's the last time he laid out a case for one of his positions *not* related to likeability instead of only tearing down pols? As important as humbling the mighty is, I'd like to see a cogent argument somewhere, not just tidbits of what memes are going around about Kerry's charm or lack thereof.

Instead of "Kerry's Curlicues", how about "Kerry's past terms in government, explained?" How about an exegesis of the real process of legislation? Why is Dahlia Lithwick [slate.msn.com] the only journalist on Slate talking about the fact that the Bush administration may have perjured itself?

What about the Administration's long-standing order, issued by memo and reported in Slate years ago, to deny FOIA requests whenever possible more of an issue rather than a one-shot? We've armchair quarterbacked Iraq into the ground from Slate, but we rarely hear of the estimated >11,000 civilian casualties there [www.iraqbodycount.net]? How does that play into a "just war"?

The Middle East is tricky situation. But Bush has talked a lot and little has happened. What are the minutiae of what's been said and done behind doors? Why no examination of the degree to which the Israeli economy is dependent on US funding, or examination of the facts-on-the-ground in Palestine -- we've heard Arafat's Fatah has "ties" to terrorist groups, but that's all we've heard for years. What ties? Has he ordered anything? How do other Palestinians feel about him?

How pertinent is it in Iraq that a majority wants us to leave? How can we take "sovereignty" with any seriousness when Iraq's "sovereign government" appears to be unswayed by the opinion of 57% of its constituency [www.usatoday.com], which wants the "allied" forces gone immediately? Beyond the "selling out" of the Kurds, how are things there? What is the history of the region? How might a pullout work? Where's the debate even of a pullout in Slate? Only this piece [slate.msn.com] even jokes about it.

How do the claims made in the pile of books about the Bush Admin line up? House of Bush, House of Saud, Plan of Attack, etc etc... We get synopses, but do the claims of the disparate elements line up? Do they not? What do they say, when taken together, about the Administration? Are they bunk? Do they not add up? If they do, why isn't this a major theme of the media -- if there really is 6-20 books worth of problems with the Bush Administration, isn't that more important than what abstractions he uses in his next press conference and what that says about his campaign strategy?

No doubt not all of these suggestions would make a good story. But any one of them would damned sure be more enlightening than another installment of "Who Cares What They Do, This is What They Say".

HC
www.iamj.blogspot.com

Wednesday, June 02, 2004

Virtual Insanity is what we're livin' in...

Ah, that great prophet of our times, Jay Kay of Jamiroquai.

Read here in Slate today about the Justice Department possibly perjuring itself before the Supreme court (to jump to the "good stuff" about the perjury... er, the "bad stuff", go here).

Read here in Slate's "In other magazines" in the Weekly Standard coverage (scroll down) about how they're still trying to tie Hussein & Al-Queda. (I'm not against researching an argument, but c'mon guys -- you're really going to bat for an Administration of documented serial liars, on the least believable part of their lies...)

Also read in Slate's "IOM" the "Even the Liberal New Republic" article summaries, one saying we should use gentler force against Iraqi insurgents (crowd control of tear gas and that ilk), and another saying we need to kill more bad guys better and faster. They apparently didn't read Slate's article about how hard it is to kill every single "bad person" and leave before your mass killings turn any more "good people" into bad ones...

Palestine and Israel: The Constraints of Security

Many things yet to formulate in my head and add to the dear blog. As is de rigeur for a grad student though, I'm just going to jot this down here and hopefully expand on it in the future.

Just went to a meeting of the Pittsburgh Socialists (the ISO). Today's topic was Palestine.

My thoughts, in brief, on Palestine. It is, like all problems, not insoluble, however difficult it may seem. However, the polar opposite of what has been said must be done.

Fact: There is no authority in Palestine that can effectively control the entire populace, through persuasion or coercion.

Fact: Even Hamas has become willing to accept the idea of negotiations.

Fact: One cannot, as lampooned here, hope to just kill all the "bad people", and none of the "good people", and also simultaneously expect not to convert some of the "good people" into "bad ones" as the result of having killed some of their countrypeople.

Considering the current state of things now, this seems implausible and out of place, but I've thought to myself for a while: The only way for this messy situation to be turned into a peaceful two-state direction is if Israel determines that it can accept some level of aggressive action from Palestine without retaliation.

This is an immensely unpopular viewpoint, to the point that I haven't heard anyone say it before. But the fact is, even if they wanted to, there is no authority in Palestine who COULD control all of its members -- it's called "the Palestinian Terrority" and not the "Palestinian Efficient Constitutional Democracy with Great Government Infrastructure" for a reason. There is the debatable point about whether the negotiating parties on the Palestinian side have actually wanted or tried to stop all the violence they could; but to a point, that's irrelevant. They condone some level of violence because they feel they must in order to keep support (this has another reasonable side: groups like Hamas are also one of the very few groups able to provide *any* social services in the region, and have popularity for that and not necessarily for their violent actions). It's reasonable to think that once a negotiation got past a theoretical stage, violence would peak (as truly anti-Israeli forces got desperate), and then subside as the average Palestinian "on the street" (or "in the horribly crowded, woefully underequipped and underserviced 'settlement camp'") began to feel progress was actually being made and begin to see violence as truly counterproductive. It's counterproductive even now, but when there are very few choices left to you, violence becomes, sadly, a rational act.

Of course, beyond the difficulties I've already mentioned, it seems doubtful Sharon wants to negotiate now, even if the news that Hamas does is true... (the discussion leader today pointed out that after Hamas offered an olive branch, "targeted killings" (read: assasinations) were stepped up by the Israelis... if true, "partners in peace" rings more hollow than usual).

J

Monday, May 31, 2004

More Grist for the Mill

Still hardly definitive, but nonetheless another webpage explaining the problems with comparative advantage/free trade models. More to come.

http://www.speakeasy.org/~peterc/wto/theory.htm

Hot time in the old town tonight

There's a lively debate (or at least, a debate) going on between Geoff and I on multiple fronts over at Geoffland. When I first read his blog, I hadn't realized we disagreed fundamentally on so many things; but he's got a really thoughtful blog, so I guess this may be my first test of my supposed motto of taking all well-thought comers (and accepting the possibility they may be right, until I can argue otherwise).

A current contention between us is basically the old "free trade: good or bad?" argument. (I'll assume for starters that he's not a big Noam Chomsky fan.)

I hope to develop my essays on this more fully in the future, but here's some initial free trade bits about how I feel:

1) The theory of comparative advantage doesn't apply.
You heard me. This is one of the arguments trotted out for free trade (tellingly though, it seems like this argument slips away under serious contention and the benefits to the US personally come to replace it). Although our neoclassical/neoliberal economists seem to have slinked away from John Maynard Keynes and David Ricardo insofar as they've taken some of their ideas and declared them brilliant, and others and declared them bunk, despite the fact that in some cases the brilliant ideas depended logically on the so-called bunk ones. Comparative advantage, specifically, made an assumption of relatively fixed capital, which is not the case for much of today's trade. In other words, Ricardo anticipated that when Country A and Country B had different production possibility horizons (I think that's the term), say, Country A is best at making wine and B is best at making, I don't know, bread, it made sense for each one to specialize. This being the case under the assumption that A has something B can't get that makes it better, and vice versa -- i.e. wine in France depends a lot on local soil conditions, and such conditions can't easily be moved or substituted in other places. Cost of labor was not a comparative advantage in the original formulation. (I know, I know, I need to source all this... no time today, it'll come.) The fact that we can pay people in other countries very little money to make stuff isn't an immovable capital; and by the same token, most capital *is* movable today, in that you can build a car factory almost anywhere. And Keynes himself made an argument for some degree of lessened trade in one of his later works: "I sympathize, therefore, with those who would minimize, rather than with those who would maximize, economic entanglement among nations. Ideas, knowledge, science, hospitality, travel--these are the things which should of their nature be international. But let goods be homespun whenever it is reasonably and conveniently possible, and, above all, let finance be primarily national. Yet, at the same time, those who seek to disembarrass a country of its entanglements should be very slow and wary. It should not be a matter of tearing up roots but of slowly training a plant to grow in a different direction. For these strong reasons, therefore, I am inclined to the belief that, after the transition is accomplished, a greater measure of national self-sufficiency and economic isolation among countries than existed in 1914 may tend to serve the cause of peace, rather than otherwise." (This quote would also be a good jumping off point for a copyright/patent flaw discussion, but some other time.)


Of course, some just took this as proof he was looney in his old age (and he did follow this paragraph by saying "each will remain entitled to his own opinion" in these questions of "doubtful judgement"). Methinks assuming he was crazy cuz he started disagreeing with modern ideology, well... that's more than a bit condescending...

2) National borders are relatively impermeable to labor.
This strikes many people as a good thing (keeps out the 'unwashed masses' and all that). I'm not going to make a statement on immigration/emigration per se, but rather that it was my understanding that under economic assumptions, labor is mobile -- i.e. labor is able to flow to the place where there is most demand (i.e. labor can fetch the highest price), such that efficiency is achieved because those who are able to do the work at the best (lowest) price will compete down the price of labor, and efficiency results (invisible hand and all that). That may appear to be what's happening; but the fact is, if there is a global capital and goods market that flows from country to country, the labor market should follow suit. In other words, labor should move as freely between countries as money, capital, and goods. I doubt many argue that this is currently the case. Thus, the fact that most labor is anchored in other countries (i.e. not every Thai worker can immigrate here to the US) is a barrier to economic efficiency, as far as I understand (again, hopefully this will be sourced later). It would seem prima facie that a market where companies (and company headquarters) move freely from country to country, and Ford and Dow and all can build factories wherever they wish, that the laborers should have as much ability to move, in order to balance the market. I would say, for example, until the victims of The Bhopal Disaster can move to the US and enjoy the same protections and responsibilities available here, that "free market" just means "capturing those who can't do any better." A labor pool unable to compete for better labor prices seems unlike economic efficiency to me.

3) The export of environmental problems is a severe cost that is not mitigated by regulations in countries we export it to.
Environmental problems are almost always externalities. They are not sufficiently enforced here in the US; they certainly are not sufficiently enforced abroad. And the idea that wealth (i.e. higher GDP) will bring environmental improvement (the so-called Environmental Kuznets Curve) has been shown repeated to be false (links to come). In other words, exporting our industries to other countries seems to gaurantee them environmental problems now and for an indefinite amount of time into the future. See work by Daniel Faber, for a start.

4) The US has no INTEREST in free trade.
Actual free trade is composed of some kind of quid-pro-quo (unless you understand the use of force or the threat of the use of force as a valid economic tool). As has been commented many times before, competition is *good* for economic efficiency; but all companies will naturally try and minimize competition, which will tend to drive up costs and/or drive down profits (i.e. in a perfectly efficient economy, all chances for profits should be immediately exploited and rapidly diminish to a lower equilibrium). So other countries becoming economic rivals to the US should be a good thing for consumers, right?

Perhaps. But we won't allow that to happen. Intervention in Nicaragua, Colombia, Argentina, Mexico, and pre-revolution Cuba, as well as many other places, has tried to put a stop to people too ambitious for economic independence (i.e. possible generators of competition). In Guatemala, Jacobo Arbenz (the democratically elected president in 1951) was overthrown by the US when he tried to expropriate unused United Fruit Company land, while offering the price that *their tax filings said it was worth*. This expropriation was for the purpose of land/agrarian reform (widespread land distribution is said by some economists to be necessary before an economy can be "developed"; i.e. the squatters of early US history); UFC insisted the land was worth some 20 or 30 times what they had reported for tax purposes (the strong implication being "of course we valued it downward to assess it for tax, but as for it's actual worth, of course that's much higher" -- in otherwords -- "what do you mean we can't screw you twice?"). A CIA operation, under the approval of Pres. Eisenhower (and under the guise of fighting the Communist threat) helped topple Arbenz and replace him with a brutal dictator. (So I'm going to have to disagree with Geoff when he says the US is "the nation most willing to consistently apply [our ideals]", though he admits our failure to sometimes "realize" them.) This is not asimilar to the US' toppling of the Iranian president and installation of the Shah. (A detailed search of FOIA about our extra-national activities is a long-term goal of the J Continuum. Stay tuned.)

The US has shown a willingness to crush any other country that poses a serious challenge to our economic interests.

This does not create a healthy international market, imho.

More on the flaws with capitalist dogma at a later date.

-J

Saturday, May 29, 2004

HI MJ!!!!

My friend "MJ" is having a shitty day. (MJ is neither me, nor Mary Jane of Spiderman Spousal fame.)

Everyone wave and say "HI, BEE!" (a nickname), and wish her a happy day and brightest blessings and good energy.

-J

Tuesday, May 25, 2004

correction

Iraq has a population of 25 million, not 15 million as written somewhere in morass below.

It's got a lovely bunch of coconuts

Go to today's Today's Papers column in Slate for a bunch of what seem to me to be VERY important tidbits.

#1: USA Today did something clever: "USA Today's subhead artfully captures the moment, "Occupation Will End Soon; Troops Remain Indefinitely." (Contrast this to the horrible Slate subheads I've complained about on Slate's Fray.)

#2: Again, from today's Today's Papers: "What do the papers do when a much-anticipated presidential speech turns out to be vacuous? They play it big and straight anyway—and in the process help mislead readers." TP regularly does a good job of pointing out a very few of the many places I feel the media's letting us down. Sadly, few people actually supposed to be receiving the information (read: everyone in the US) doesn't read TP... or watch or read the news at all. There'd be problem enough making informed public decisions with a straightforward media. How screwed are we with a misleading one?

#3: Did you LISTEN to Bush's speech? Vacuous. I agree. I figured out that's why I wasn't offended. I'd heard it all before, so there was nothing new to get angry about...

#4: #3, of course, is not directly one of the revelations from TP. But it's related...

#5: The one thing I was actually kinda excited about in the speech, the apparent shift in Iraqi sovereignty plans: no dice. As recently as April it was reported that the sovereignty would be partial. Prezzy Prez G-Dub promised "full sovereignty" yesterday so forcefully, I actually believed this was a shift! Doh. TP reveals today that "articles inside the papers say that the draft Security Council resolution the U.S. and Britain offered yesterday doesn't give it. Most crucially, it doesn't give the still unnamed temporary government the power to ask foreign troops to leave or to overrule missions." And actually reading selections from a search of the White House website confirms that there will not be "full sovereignty" given over today if by that term, you mean both "full" and "sovereignty", although the White House has been maintaining that it will give full sovereignty over on June 30th for at least a while...

#6: Recovering from my shock at the fact that "our" "President's" plan for Iraqi "sovereignty" comes with sovereignty not included (clue: start at the bottom of the transcript and work up), another TP tidbit is, somewhat unsurprisingly, the claims that Gen. Sanchez, allied commander in Iraq, "was going to be replaced anyway, and, you know, it just happened to be now, and no, we never planned to promote him, but if we ever did, we don't now, and that's completely irrelevant to what's been in the news and polls today, and to reiterate, everything's normal, everything's fine, things are completely under control" are bunk and they were not planning on pulling Sanchez, or delaying his promotion, at least according to several different sources TP synthesizes.

#7: Bush's numbers keep dropping. Yaaaaaay. If only Kerry weren't... well, where to start. But maybe Bush's numbers will get low enough that the "Left" will finally feel "safe" to vote for, well, you know, the Left candidate (Nader). Nader is not the perfect person everyone seems to demand a 3rd party candidate be. But I believe in his policies, no matter how drily (dryly? no, hm (sp)) he voices them. You know, a candidate unlike Kerry, who doesn't say "Well, I'm against gay marriage, but for civil unions, but yes I attended a gay marriage recently, but no that doesn't mean I support it, because marriage is between a man and a woman, but we shouldn't take away people's rights." I don't mind so much the man's (Kerry's) qualified, complicated answers; some things are complicated and require qualification. The problem is, he's qualifiedly equivocal on things I strongly believe in. (Is it just me, or is it REALLY bad when your candidate STARTS his major campaigning equivocally? If you can't make bold promises before you're elected, when are you going to make them? Much less bold decisions. As West Wing has "shown", once you're elected, you don't start fulfilling your promises, you start worrying about burning bridges for your re-election campaign, and midterms...)

#8: Wow, this is longer than I planned. Let's speed it up. TP Revelation 8: The Pentagon's claims of the isolatedness of abuse takes another hit, as another person has stepped forward and said he was abused (at Gitmo). Unfortunately, the Pentagon claims as always that they investigate all credible claims. This guy, I'm sure they say indulgently, just doesn't have credible claims... just like the 3(?) Iraqi Reuters employees, the AP employee, the Afghan police colonel... (ps Hey, Afghanistan, remember them? Maybe we could get the world community to follow through on their aid to Afghanistan if we drew attention to it again; out of media, out of mind. Maybe if MTV did a "I Love The 00s" or "I Love the Places We Bombed Right Before This One" -- instant nostalgia could finally do some good!)

#9: Still rambling... Apparently (still in TP) some military officers didn't like the un-Geneva-like behavior at Abu Ghraib, so they signed off on a document with the CIA that puts prisoners not supervised under the Red Cross off-the-books (so thus, they don't have to deny the Red Cross access -- they can just deny the prisoners exist). (Apparently the CIA signer was "James Bond." A nom de guerre? If so, a) is this legal, and b) in any case, can we find out if this was simply to keep any subsequent investigation from finding this CIA agent easily, or is her/his name realy James Bond? Additional bonus unresolved question: Would the agent then go by Jimmy Bond, or whatever stupid name the added cast member to the "I was born to jump the shark" series, The Lone Gunmen?)

#10: Lab closing in 15 minutes... promise to go home and work immediately after class slipping from a small fib to a large self-deception... TP's last point is that the ~2,000 missing pages from the Congress' copy of the Taguba report on US prisoner abuses may include a section ("Draft Update") explicitly for SecDef "Known knowns, known unknowns, and unknown unknowns" Rummy, who said he never read the report (and perhaps added, "I may or may not have been the SecDef when it happened, or indeed, the SecDef right now. And let me tell you exactly why "I'm under oath" doesn't mean what you think it does..."") (..."i do not think that word means what you think it means"... couldn't resist!) Important follow-up that pesos'll get you dollars will not be done soon by NYT, WaPo, or other major media: Did he perjure himself? What are the real facts here? Did they make a draft for him that he didn't bother to read? Isn't that bad too? (Similarly, the missing 2,000 pages is a "clerical error" or some such.)

(and not from TP but your super-bonus question for my current readership of nowt: Didn't Slate say classifying the Taguba report might've been illegal? Yes, Fred Kaplan did! Direct link to his source: here. What's up with this? If true, shouldn't someone report it on mainstream news? And shouldn't the attempt of the gov't to reclassify the report be illegal, only doubly so? sorry no link -- heard it on NPR this morning...)

And as the computer lab closes, so does this entry...

Repost from my rant on Slate's Fray

lians.

Iraqbodycount.net has compiled (complete with sources for verifiability) cross-referenced reports of civilian deaths since the beginning of 2003, counting between 9,000 and 11,000 *reported* Iraqi civilian deaths. This number (~11,000) is also quoted by the major news sources (NPR, CNN at least), though their original sources are not clear. I believe, though I'm not sure, this number was also given in the testimony taken in the past month of Pentagon officials before Congress.

As this is de rigeur, I vociferously confirm that Hussein was murderous and genocidal. I can't yet figure out why it is necessary to point this out when arguing *not* that he's a good person, but rather that our actions is deposing this bad person were ill-advised (i.e. the one doesn't imply a negation of the other, making "Well do you like Saddam Hussein" something of a Straw Man). But there it is. Nevertheless, Human Rights Watch, whom I would think some deference should be paid in this matter, does not consider the Iraq war a humanitarian intervention. (Of greater importance of course would be how Iraqis view it; I would say the earlier (2003) Zogby poll is equivocal; the recent USAT/CNN/Gallup Poll shows that Iraqis today, by large margins, think their country has been hurt by the war, it wasn't worth it, and conditions are the same or worse than they were before.) Considering the fact that the Iraqis did not and increasingly *do not* see the war as good for them, and the fact that 11,000 of their countrywomen and men and children have died, well--

Do you, Mr. Noah, consider your estimation of the war's good to be more important than that of those in the place we're supposed to be "saving"? And do you think that the loss of 11,000 lives makes an intervention thought to be humanitarian almost solely by us, who have lost ~800 lives (as well as 3,000 in the *unrelated* 9/11 attacks), just? Are we the ones to pronounce our work "good", and take a day of rest once we "finish"?

A last thought: we felt it was a world gone mad when 3,000 of our citizens (and a number of citizens of 80 other countries) died horribly in an act of pure hatred. 3,000 people out of 300 million.

The Iraqis have lost 11,000 civilians (and some several thousand Iraqi soldiers) in our "just war" (that, I reiterate, has no immediate logical connection to the primarily Saudi men involved in 9/11). 11,000 Iraqi civilians (~15,000 Iraqis total) in a country of 15 million. I an country 1/20th of our size, they lost 5 times as many people. Do they count less? Do we count more?

Does a noble cause someone devalue the worth of a life? Are 15,000 dead more justifiable than 3,000 because, at best/naivest, one action was one of hope, and the other of anger?

I believe, given the circumstances, this is not a rhetorical question. The answer is no.

Monday, May 24, 2004

post script

PS: A site I highly recommend on GP is Poor Mojo's Almanac(k). Go there. Now. Read of the Squid. And other things.

PPS: The aforementioned Jef once wondered aloud to me why people use Post Scripts in electronic communication. After all, he reasoned, the original raison d'etre for post scripts was so you wouldn't have to rewrite/retype a whole sheet to fit it in. In email, you can just scroll up and fix it. Hmm.

PPPS: I figured out the reason (not just now, actually, the PPPS is for dramatic/annoying effect): it negates the need for segues, so difficult in the braindump that often is an email (or blog posting).

A gente se fala.

"Are You HopefulCynic?" "I hope so, I'm wearing his underwear."

I really should tell some people (i.e. any people) that I have a blog. I don't feel that it's particularly likely anyone will look at this otherwise. Yessssss. (Said like Mr. Burns, with fingers steepled.)

I just had an idea that I wanted to put out there for any eventual readers... my friend Jef & I had long ago (3 years ago?) thought about making a magazine called "Il Manifesto" (before we knew there was some Italian magazine by that name; pesos'll get you dollars that it is in some way connected to PM Berlusconi (subparenthetical comment: no, they won't -- despite Berlusconi's Eliot Carver-like media monopoly (Carver, villain of Bond flick "Tomorrow Never Dies") in Italy, Il Manifesto is, somewhat unsurprisingly, an independent communist daily. Duh.)).

The (to us) funny irony would be that Il Manifesto would have no manifesto, in terms of explicit political agenda -- we'd publish anything that was well argued. (There is, of course, the question of what counts as well argued. Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh, and Bill O'Reilly makes sense to some people. Christopher Hitchens, for god's sake, apparently still makes sense to somebody, because they still publish him at Slate. Same for Mickey Kaus. Personally, I think Fred Kaplan usually makes a hell of a lot of sense, which for others, simply proves that I'm biased. But I digress.) Further, I think, we'd have a running commentary, so we could attempt to actually *synthesize* some knowledge. A friend of a friend, who is an ex-journalist, wasn't immediately familiar with the idea of writing synthetically (random googled link to synthesis here), apparently because journalism is supposed to only report facts, and not synthesize, this apprarently being the reader's job. (Rant on this to come.) There's some sense in this, but as synthesis must start somewhere (i.e. despite the fact there are competing claims about, say, the Holocaust, or the earth's roundness, most media have already synthesized the claims into what seems to emerge as the facts of each case), why not explicitly do more of it? Not in all news, to be sure, and there's also the "arc" problem, like with TV shows -- how do you attract readers midway if they have to have read the previous ones to understand? Luckily, I am not the TV show Angel, and I'm not the WB, so I don't have to worry about ratings. If I'm lucky, someday I'll have the chance to sell my soul, only to choose to stay comparitively obscure and stay true to myself. Or something.

So the original (and originally short) idea I had was to do "Il Manifesto" here on Blogspot. So if anyone reads this, and has (what they think are) well-reasoned arguments on (practically) anything, I'd like to start it up. I had the idea while... er, on a "thinking throne", of a Group webBlog, or as I thought of it, a Grog. I then tried to think of a way to make it mesh with "Grok" (basically, to understand/absorb completely into your being; to symbolically (usually) eat an idea), like "The Grogk", or just "Grok" or "The Grok Grog."

They look pretty clumsy, writing them now.

Alas.

If anyone's outthere sometime, feel free to contact me via comments on the Continuum (this Blog).

Tchau.

Sunday, May 23, 2004

If she can see farther than other people, it's because other people aren't as cool.

Oh, yeah -- I wanted to recommend to my readers (all none of you) that you read BeverlyMann's blog. She's a fellow poster to Slate, the neoliberal webmag (though I'm not sure she knows of me, as we've never directly exchanged comments I think). She is "BeverlyMann" on Slate as well, so you can look up her comments on that site's "The Fray", the discussion bulletin board. If you want to read stuff I've written up 'till now, of the general sort I'm starting this blog for, look up HopefulCynic.

Tchau,

J

Heyo, everybody.

So, I spent several hours yesterday compiling my thoughts into a jumble of Googled research on drinking and alcoholism (as part of a greater exegesis on counterintuitive/postnormal science).

Bottom line conclusion: USA's "Pffff, other COUNTRIES?" approach to believing in science (and disbelieving results in other civilizations) is, as usual, wrong, this time in regards to drinking. Binge drinking is lower in so-called "wet" cultures (places like France, Italy, and Germany where drinking is part of everyday life and not necessarily something banned so draconically until 21), and *much* higher in "dry" countries (UK, Ireland, Norway I think), though cirrhosis and other long-term problems are worse, generally, in "wet" countries. (But on the other hand, France has had huge success in cutting everyday drinking and cirrhosis by about 50%, in part by draconian rules on liqour advertising, i.e. NONE at sporting events... try to imagine that in the US w/o your head exploding.)

I'll post a link later, but if you google for ECAS (European Council(?) Alcohol Survey?), you'll find some of the 'fo.

Also, in counterintuitive/other COUNTRIES news, Slate (www.slate.com) recently had an article about how gay marriage has *not* destroyed hetero marriage in Scandinavia. (Raise your hand if you're surprised.) (Ok, you, you there with your hand up: yeah, you. Slap yourself.) I suppose this isn't exactly counterintuitive (it seems rather reasonable to me), but I guess it fits into the larger "counterintuitive" theme -- at best there's inconclusive evidence that a culture more accepting of diverse sexuality actually *encourages* it. Kids seem to grow up straight or gay somewhat independent of their parent's sexuality (though again this is not scientifically concrete). The whole "that which is verboten I must do" ethic does seem to be an unavoidable side-effect, though, in both drinking and sexuality. (Cf. also birth control/contraceptive use, and, you guessed it, other countries' success in teaching these without necessarily increasing teenage sexuality. I'll google some links to this later.)

Anyway, before I lose this post too to computer malfuckntion, the reason I've drawn you here today: this is sort of a lackluster first post, but I've been fiendishly reading exegeses of the Matrix movies (or as I prefer, the Matrices), and I am proud to say that I was right and most everyone else was wrong. There's a whole MESS of imagery and very well-done deliberate story weaving there, ESPECIALLY in the second one. This confirms (in part) my theory that US audiences are hostile to movies that exist on both a semi-literal and subtextual level. (I've forgotten my other examples, but they're there dammit.) So to read a quite *excellent* analysis of the last two Matrices, go here and here. I cannot claim to be anywhere as smart or well-read as these guys, but I'm kinda proud that I saw the tip of the massive iceberg they uncovered.

P.s. YAY!

It's always nice not to be the lone voice in the woods (is that from Emerson? Am I making that up?).

Alas, I can't think of any clever uses of my new matrix-knowledge to vampishly pun here, so I'll post this before it goes away.

If I can see farther than other (hu)man(s), it's because other (hu)man(s) are short-sighted,

J